- Australian Financial Review
McCormick says Mayfair 101’s growth may one day call into question the regulator’s role in monitoring wholesale investors
Mayfair 101The regulator's role is to uphold the ASIC Act and Corporations Act. Their role is not to monitor wholesale investors. An individual either qualifies (and their accountant confirms they qualifiy)...
ClarificationSubjective - Australian Financial Review
The flattery includes testimonials from a widow who just sold the family home and was “all alone and had no idea what to do”.
Mayfair 101This client was one of over 500 clients who were satisfied with their commercial relationship with Mayfair 101 until ASIC attacked the group shortly after this article being published.
ClarificationMisleadingDefamatory - Australian Financial Review
McCormick doubts whether all of Mayfair Platinum’s investors are truly sophisticated enough to assess the financial risks, and whether they can afford to lose their money.
Mayfair 101Mr McCormick's views are a question of law, not of Mayfair's business. Mayfair complied with its statutory requirements to only accept monies from wholesale clients.
ClarificationMisleading - Australian Financial Review
Mayfair’s light disclosures didn’t seem to trouble many people at the seminar
Mayfair 101Most of the attendees had about 20+ years more commercial experience than the journalist. They understood they were lenders and not actual investors in specific projects. It is a shame the...
AccurateClarification - Australian Financial Review
The group's corporate structure is a spaghetti bowl of shareholdings, funds and loans, in Australia and the UK.
Mayfair 101There was no spaghetti bowl. The journalists had never interviewed Mr Mawhinney or any staff member, and not seen a corporate structure diagram, and therefore was in no position to make this...
MisleadingClarificationFalse - Australian Financial Review
has law and commerce degrees from the University of Western Australia
Mayfair 101This demonstrates how the journalists mischaracterised Mr Mawhinney as a 'marketing maven' when they had full knowledge of his formal qualifications.
Accurate - Australian Financial Review
Sharp-suited marketing maven
Mayfair 101Mr Mawhinney's formal qualifications are in Law and Commerce.
MisleadingMistaken - Australian Financial Review
the staffer testified to receiving no performance warnings
Mayfair 101The requirements of the role were clearly set out. The staff member was notified they failed to meet their targets. There was no basis to bring the claim.
Clarification - Australian Financial Review
he was personally castigated for “evasive conduct” by the Fair Work Commission in his time there
Mayfair 101There was no evasive conduct. The one and only time Mr Mawhinney has been to Fair Wark was in relation to a sales representative who was terminated because they did not achieve sales targets. It...
Clarification - Australian Financial Review
“This is what happens when a marketing executive tries to become an investment professional,” he says.
Mayfair 101Mr McGowan did not do his research on Mr Mawhinney's qualifications, which are a Bachelor of Law and Bachelor of Commerce with an Investment Finance major. It appears Mr McGowan doesn't hold any...
DefamatoryMisleadingMistaken - Australian Financial Review
There is “no transparency around their portfolio”, he says.
Mayfair 101This is because Mayfair 101 was not operating a funds management business. Mr McGowan failed to appreciate this critical point.
ClarificationMistaken - Australian Financial Review
Tim McGowen, of Informed Investor, has been vocal in his concerns about the IPO Wealth and Mayfair Platinum offerings.
Mayfair 101Mr McGowen is a failed fund manager that became a journalist. He was in no position to comment other than in an entirely speculative capacity.
Clarification - Australian Financial Review
Unfortunately I think in five years' time we will see permanent loss of capital for those members of our community who can least afford it.
Mayfair 101This was a quote by NAB's director Mr Peeyush Gupta. Mayfair 101 contacted Mr Gupta to see if he made this quote in relation to Mayfair 101 considering it was positioned high up in the article with...
DefamatoryMisleadingOut of context - Australian Financial Review
That’s because unlike a bank that raises safe deposits to lend out to businesses and consumers, Mawhinney is using the cheap funds to back his own speculative investments.
Mayfair 101The journalists have micharacterised Mayfair 101's private equity portfolio which comprised approximately 25 distinct investments at the time. A significant portion of the portfolio was Australian...
DefamatoryFalseMisleading - Australian Financial Review
And while he stresses these investments carry more risk than money in the bank, even those comparisons are questionable.
Mayfair 101A risk warning was provided. The journalists have mischaracterised what was a normal disclaimer.
AccurateClarification - Australian Financial Review
Across three Mayfair-related offerings, Mawhinney says he’s raised about $180 million from investors and has $500 million of assets under management.
Mayfair 101This is why the regulator's action against Mayfair 101 did not make any sense.
Accurate - Australian Financial Review
But the marketing blitz of new operators worries some.
Mayfair 101The "some" Mr Shapiro refers to is the person who was seated next to him at the event Mayfair held in Sydney on 26 November 2019 - Domenic McCormick.
ClarificationMisleading - Australian Financial Review
The island is all anyone appears to want to discuss at the seminar to promote his Mayfair Platinum funds.
Mayfair 101This quote highlights the journalists' lack of knowledge about Mayfair 101. Mayfair Platinum did not offer funds! Our group never charged anyone to manage their money. There is a distinct...
ClarificationMistakenMisleading Unlock FREE access to Media.com
Enter your email address for access and updates
Media.com will not share your information with third parties. By submitting this form you agree to our Privacy Policy. You can change your cookie settings on our Cookies page
Australian Financial ReviewI'm no Skase
Mayfair 101Mr Mawhinney did not say 'I'm no Skase' at the event. We have this on video. The journalists have misquoted him to create the impression he was the equivalent of international fugitive Christopher...
MisquotedDefamatoryMisleading